Ice Cream



Discover why the Star Ledger exclaims it to be “outrageous”.

Our homemade Ice Cream and Italian Gelato are made on premise daily. We use pure vanilla, rich Dutch chocolates, real fruits, fresh nuts and imported purees and flavors to produce a super-premium ice cream and authentic Gelato. The secret recipe of all our products is the finest ingredients, professionally made with a touch of love.

Just one taste and you will know what makes our ice cream award winning. With 150+ flavors to tempt you, it will be an experience you won’t forget. Our hand picked staff will serve our homemade ice cream with a smile, ask for a sample today.

From our family recipes we make small batches for freshness unmatched anywhere.

24 of these rich, decadent flavors are available at the South Street Creamery today. Check our American Ice Cream page for Today’s flavors.

After Dinner mint • Almond Joy • Apple Cranberry Crumb • Apple Pie • Baileys • Banana • Bananaberry • Banana Chip • Banana Cream Pie • Banana Nut Fudge • Banana Split • Banilla Bash • Blackberry • Blackberry Cobbler • Black Raspberry • Black Raspberry Chip • Blueberry • Blueberry Cheesecake • Blueberry Chip • Blueberry Ripple or Crumb • Brown Cow Oreo • Bubble Gum • Butter Crunch • Butter Pecan • Candy Cane (Seasonal) • Caramel Apple • Cherry Vanilla • Cherry Vanilla Chip • Chocolate • Chocolate Amaretto • Chocolate Banana • Chocolate Brownie • Chocolate Butter Almond • Chocolate Cheesecake • Chocolate Cherry • Chocolate Chip • Chocolate Fluffanutter • Chocolate Fudge Brownie • Chocolate Heathbar • Chocolate Mousse • Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup • Chocolate Peanut Butter Oreo • Chocolate Raspberry Truffle • Cinnamon Bun • Cinnamon Oreo • Coconut • Coconut Cream Pie • Coconut Fudge • Coffee • Coffee Chocolate Chip • Coffee Truffle • Cookie Dough • Cotton Candy • Death by Chocolate • Dreamsicle (Creamsicle) • Dulce De Leche • Egg Nog • English Toffee • French Toast • French Vanilla • Ginger Bread • Great Swamp • Heathbar Caramel Crunch • Heavenly Hash • Ice - Lemon • Ice - Watermelon • Ice - Cherry • Ice - Orange • Ice - Blue Raspberry • Ice - Rainbow • Ice - Root Beer • Jamaican Cherry Chip • Jockey Hollow • Kahlua Madness • Key Lime Pie • Lemon Meringue Pie • Maple Walnut • Midnight Oreo (Choc Oreo) • Mint Chocolate Chip • Mocha Almond Fudge • Mocha Chip • Mocha Cookie Pie • Mocha Crunch • Oreo Cookies-n-Cream • Peaches and Cream • Peach Melba • Peanut Butter Brownie • Peanut Butter Cookie Dough • Peanut Butter Cup • Peanut Butter & Jelly • Peppermint Patty • Pistachio • Pralines and Cream • Pumpkin • Pumpkin Praline • Rocky Road • Root Beer Float • Rum Raisin • Sherbet- Key Lime • Sherbet-Strawberry • Sherbet - Red Raspberry • Sherbet - Pina Colada • Sherbet - Very Berry • S'Morristown • Snickers • Somoa • Sorbet - Champagne • Sorbet - Peach • Sorbet - Pear • Sorbet - Strawberry • Sorbet- Blueberry • Sorbet- Chocolate • Sorbet- Key Lime • Sorbet- Pina Colada • Sorbet- Raspberry • Sorbet- Watermelon • Sorbet- Lemon • Spumoni Strawberry • Strawberry Cheesecake • Strawberry Daiquiri • Sugar Free Irish Crème • Sugar Free Kahlua Fudge • Sugar Free Mint Fudge • Sugar Free Peanut Butter • Sugar Free Vanilla • Sweet Cream • • Sweet Mango • Tiramisu • Turtle Fudge • Vanilla • Vanilla Bean • Fudge • Vanilla Fudge Almond • Wild Berry Blast

And many more…


South Street Creamery & Cafe
146 South Street, Morristown, NJ  07960
Voice: 973-267-8887     FAX: 973-267-8030     Email
view map