South Street Creamery
& Red Sea Café
Morristown’s Oldest Operating Ice Cream Shop and Newest East African Café!
Homemade Ice Cream
& Gelato
Made with 100% Real Vanilla Extract, Dutch Cocoa Powder, and Always-Natural Ingredients. No Artificial Flavors.
Lite Bites, Espresso
Drinks & Café Meals
From Italian-Influenced Paninis to French-Inspired Crepes, with a Now-Expanded Dinner of Eritrean Dishes.
Co-Packing
& Custom Flavors
With Homemade Treats, Roasted Nuts, Ice Creams, and Gelatos, we’re here to fulfill your event needs.
Breakfast
Served every weekday morning from 9:30am to 11:00am, our breakfast offers a number of light meals and bites that are sure to start your day off right.
For larger events and catering needs, we’re also available to deliver boxed drinks, breakfast sandwich trays, fruit salads, and other treats for any time that you need it! Just call us at 973-267-8887 and ask for Karol or Amleset.
Lunch
The most famous part of our Café menus, our Lunch Menu features a variety of light bite options to satisfy even the deepest mid-day cravings. Whether in the form of our homemade soups or our carefully crafted crepes, salads, and sandwiches, our menu uses the freshest ingredients from the best sources, with recipes crafted over 20 years from the Garcia and Williams families.
To help keep this commitment, everything we offer is always homemade: slow-roasting all our meats and vegetables, slicing our cheeses, baking our focaccia, mixing our crepe batter, and preparing all of our own dressings, chutneys, and spreads. It’s just our way to help guarantee the best possible experience (and quality) every time you come to our store.
Dinner
Open by reservation between 5-8pm Monday thru Friday, the South Street Creamery’s new dinner menu features an Eritrean-Italian fusion of seasonings and flavors.
Some of these dishes, like our Cranberry & Feta Pizzette and our Kids Mac & Cheese, are iconic recipes crafted from the Creamery’s book of recipes. But others, like our Lentil Birsen or Mushroom Kantisha, include spices and descriptions only familiar to those who have tried East African Cuisine, from Red Pepper Seasoning and Clarified Butter to our Eritrean Sweet Bread and Teff Injera.
Eritrean Dinner Reviews
“Wow the Eritrean dinner was insane!!! SO good. I’ve been waiting for a place that serves amazing food like this in Morristown- so delicious!! Also I realized I didn’t get a chance to snap a picture because I ate it all too quickly. Food was so good I immediately went to Google to write a review which I normally don’t do.
Also the staff was super nice about accommodating my order. A must try for sure!”
-Andrea Chan
“The best lentils, shiro & spinach you’ll find in NJ!! Mouthwateringly delicious. The avocado & tomato salad was an excellent compliment to the main dishes. Highly recommended!”
-Samuel Tesfaye
“We went to the Creamery/Cafe for a late lunch at 1 O’clock today.
Although their Eritrean menu says available by reservation 5 to 8 pm. we were able to order from the dinner menu.
Service was prompt and very friendly.
The Eritrean food was novel and delicious.
Many, varied, interesting items to choose from.
A pleasant contrast and relief from the usual hamburger, steak, pizza, sushi, etc. choices at most other restaurants in the Morristown area.”
-John Flory
Past Special Projects
Whether co-packing for a formal business or requesting a special flavor and ice cream tub for a community event, we at the South Street Creamery & Red Sea Café are happy to design a truly unique and custom experience for your friends, family, coworkers, and customers. Just call us at 973-267-8887 (and ask for Karol or Amleset) to learn more!
Spoonful of Sugar
MHS Production of Mary Poppins
Fruit Loops Ice Cream
Co-Packing for Corporate Client