Homemade Ice Cream & Gelato
With a longstanding commitment to using all-natural ingredients, including real vanilla and 100% Dutch cocoa, there’s a reason our store is the oldest ice cream shop still operating in Morristown.
Shop Favorites
Our flavors regularly rotate as we experiment with different flavors, partnerships with local communities, and seasonal events. However, some remain our store staples and are almost always available. These include:
Vanilla: made with Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla
Chocolate: made with 100% real Dutch cocoa
Strawberry: made always with (pounds and pounds of) real strawberries
Cookies & Cream: an Oreo crowd-favorite!
Sweet Cream: the base for all of our ice creams
Coffee: real coffee means real caffeine
Cherry Vanilla: real vanilla and swirls of cherry
Cookie Dough: a classic for a reason
Chocolate Chip Fudge: rich chocolate chunks and fudge swirled through a vanilla base
Mint Chocolate Chip: perfect for an after dinner snack or just a mid-day treat
Butter Pecan: a rich, buttery base made always with real pecan pieces
Grandma’s Kitchen: vanilla with cake batter, chocolate frosting, and cookie dough pieces
Kahlua Madness: a Kahlua-Coffee base with fudge swirls and chocolate covered espresso beans
Jockey Hollow: a vanilla malt base layered with peanut butter and chocolate covered pretzels
Purple Cow Tracks: a black raspberry base with fudge and chocolate chunk pieces
Limited Edition Flavors
Updated as of Sep 4, 2024
Cake Batter: a buttery-batter base sure to delight the whole family
Cotton Candy: a kid-favorite treat so tasty you’ll swear you were at the boardwalk
Coconut: a crowd-favorite, and perfectly refreshing snack for the summer
Great Swamp: a coffee base with graham crackers and chocolate-covered almonds
Mint Fudge Brownie: a mint base with fudge swirls and brownie pieces
Brown Cow PB Oreo: a light chocolate base with peanut butter and Oreo pieces
Dulce de Leche: a caramel base with caramel swirls
Baileys Irish Cream: a boozy Baileys Irish Cream base with caramel swirls
Gelato Flavors
Updated as of Sep 4, 2024
Blueberry: a berry delicious flavor, perfect for the close of summer!
Pistachio: a classically nutty delight
Passion Fruit: sweet and tart, it’s the perfect summer treat
Dairy-Free Flavors
Updated as of Sep 4, 2024
Lemon Ice: a sharp citrus bite refreshing for any weather
Blue Raspberry Ice: a crowd favorite, and easily our most popular ice
Peach Ice: the perfect ice needed to help jump-start your day
Cherry Ice: deep red with a burst of flavor, perfect with Lemon or on its own
Watermelon Ice: refreshingly pink and tasty to boot!
Pineapple Ice: a delicious ice for pineapple lovers everywhere
Orange Ice: a blood orange base sure to satisfy any dessert need
Strawberry Ice: made with real strawberries, try our newest (and definitely creamiest) Italian ice
Strawberry Dole Whip: our staff-favorite soft serve is back!
Sugar-Free Flavors
Updated as of Sep 4, 2024
SF Chocolate Churro: a cinnamon chocolate base with caramel swirls and chocolate chip pieces — a flavor so good, you won’t be able to tell that it’s sugar free!
Soft Serve Flavors
Updated as of Sep 4, 2024
Strawberry Dole Whip: our staff-favorite vegan soft serve is back!
Vanilla Custard: an eggy summer treat
Strawberries & Cream: an English delight, try a twist of our vegan Strawberry Dole Whip and Vanilla Custard today
Vanilla Soft Serve: a classic!
Chocolate Soft Serve: delicious!
Vanilla & Chocolate Twist: a perfect pair of two outstanding flavors
Need a Custom Flavor For
Your Next Event?
Check out our past projects to see how we help craft unique flavors and
experiences for community events, parties, and corporate events.